Balance of power. Geostrategic Studies Team
Israel and Turkey are two of the most significant regional powers in the Middle East, each with unique characteristics that distinguish it from the other. Israel, a small country in terms of land and population, relies on technological superiority, military advancements, and strong ties with Western countries, particularly the United States. On the other hand, Turkey, with its strategic geographical location, possesses a large military and a diverse economy, aiming to play a key role on the global stage through its NATO membership and influence in the Islamic world.
This comparison will analyze several key aspects, including military capabilities, economic power, and political influence, to provide a comprehensive understanding of each nation's strengths and weaknesses and their impact on the regional and global landscape.
1. Military Power
Israel has one of the most advanced militaries in the region, despite having fewer soldiers compared to Turkey. The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) consist of approximately 169,000 active personnel, with an additional 465,000 reservists. In contrast, the Turkish Armed Forces (TAF) are much larger, with around 425,000 active soldiers, 200,000 reservists, and an additional 150,000 paramilitary forces in the Turkish Gendarmerie.
Air Force
Israel’s Air Force is among the most technologically advanced in the world, with around 600 aircraft, including state-of-the-art fighter jets such as the F-35, F-15, and F-16, along with an extensive fleet of drones like the Heron and Hermes. Turkey, on the other hand, has a larger fleet with over 1,050 aircraft, including more than 280 fighters, mainly F-16s, and is developing its indigenous TF-X fighter jet.
Ground Forces
Israel primarily relies on its domestically developed Merkava tanks, with approximately 1,800 in service, along with 8,000 armored vehicles. Turkey surpasses Israel in numbers, with around 3,000 tanks, including the German-made Leopard 2 and M60, while also developing its indigenous Altay tank. Turkey also operates over 12,000 armored vehicles.
Naval Power
Turkey has a significantly larger and more diverse navy, with a fleet of 150 ships, including 12 submarines, 16 frigates, and an amphibious assault carrier, TCG Anadolu, which enhances its maritime capabilities. In contrast, Israel lacks large naval assets such as frigates or aircraft carriers but operates five advanced Dolphin-class submarines, which are believed to be capable of launching nuclear missiles.
Nuclear Capabilities
Israel is believed to possess between 90 and 400 nuclear warheads, along with advanced Jericho ballistic missiles capable of delivering nuclear payloads. Turkey does not have nuclear weapons, but it hosts U.S. nuclear bombs under NATO agreements and is working on developing long-range missile systems.
Defense Industry
Israel is a global leader in defense technology, with companies like Rafael, Israel Aerospace Industries (IAI), and Elbit Systems producing cutting-edge military equipment. Turkey has made significant progress in recent years, with companies like ASELSAN, ROKETSAN, and Baykar developing advanced weapons, including the highly successful Bayraktar TB2 and Akinci drones.
---
2. Economic Power
Israel has a highly developed and innovation-driven economy, with a Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of around $550 billion and a high per capita income of $58,000 per year. The economy is based on high-tech industries, defense technology, and agriculture, along with growing energy exports.
Turkey’s economy is larger in terms of total GDP, at approximately $1.1 trillion, but faces challenges such as high inflation (exceeding 50% in 2024) and a weakening currency. Turkey’s per capita GDP is significantly lower than Israel’s, at about $13,000 per year.
In terms of trade, Israel exports around $165 billion worth of goods annually, focusing on technology and military products, whereas Turkey exports approximately $250 billion, with key industries including automotive manufacturing, textiles, electronics, and drone production.
3. Political Influence and International Relations
Regional and Global Influence
Israel enjoys strong support from the United States and maintains military and economic partnerships with European and Asian countries such as India and Germany. Its regional influence has expanded through normalization agreements with the UAE, Bahrain, Morocco, and Sudan, strengthening its strategic position in the Middle East.
Turkey, as a NATO member, plays a significant geopolitical role, with strong ties in the Middle East, the Caucasus, and the Balkans. Despite tensions with some Western allies, Turkey remains a key player in global affairs, particularly in conflicts such as the Syrian Civil War, the Mediterranean disputes, and the Libyan and Azerbaijani conflicts.
Soft Power
Israel relies on technological advancements, diplomatic lobbying, and defense cooperation to expand its influence. Turkey, meanwhile, benefits from its cultural exports, including popular TV series, Ottoman heritage, and its positioning as a leader in the Muslim world.
Intelligence Capabilities
Israel’s Mossad is regarded as one of the most effective intelligence agencies in the world, known for executing sophisticated covert operations against its adversaries. Turkey’s National Intelligence Organization (MIT) has also grown in capability but does not match Mossad’s global reach.
4. Conflicts and Security Challenges
Israel faces ongoing threats from Iran, Hezbollah, and Palestinian factions and frequently conducts airstrikes in Syria, Lebanon, and Gaza. Turkey deals with different security challenges, including Kurdish insurgencies, conflicts in Syria, tensions in the Eastern Mediterranean, and its military interventions in Libya and Azerbaijan.
Final Comparison and Conclusions
Military Power: Israel leads in technology, while Turkey has numerical superiority.
Air Force Superiority: Israel has the edge due to F-35 jets and advanced drone capabilities.
Ground Forces: Turkey has a larger army with more tanks and armored vehicles.
Naval Power: Turkey has a stronger and more diverse navy.
Nuclear Capabilities: Israel holds a strategic advantage with its nuclear arsenal.
Economic Strength: Turkey has a larger economy, but Israel’s is more stable and innovation-driven.
Political Influence: Israel is more influential in the West, while Turkey dominates regional politics.
Intelligence Superiority: Mossad outperforms Turkey’s MIT in covert operations.
Security Challenges: Israel faces Iran and Hezbollah, while Turkey has multiple conflicts in its region.
In conclusion, Israel is a high-tech military powerhouse with strong international backing, while Turkey is a regional heavyweight with a large army and growing global ambitions. Each country has its own strengths and challenges, making them both influential players in the Middle East and beyond.
